The Pizza Sauce - 2025

 

IN SHORT…

This is where it all began. The Pizza Sauce was the first hot sauce Tim ever came up with; while eating a cheap slice of pizza one day ten or twelve years ago he thought he could make it immeasurably better by deepening its flavors with a slightly spicy, umami-rich sauce, one that echoes all the flavors found in those little shaker jars at East Coast pizza shops. And he has been making it - off and on - ever since.

Food Pairings: while its name makes its primary mission clear, this sauce is a versatile companion for all things Italian-American. Beyond the pizza box, it brings a vibrant kick to meatball subs, chicken parmesan, or a hearty plate of baked ziti.

  • This sauce was low-temperature pasteurized and preserved with calcium disodium EDTA (to maintain color and inhibit rancidity) and ascorbic acid (to prevent oxidation). While technically shelf stable, we would strongly recommend keeping it refrigerated to help preserve its flavor.

  • Common Allergens: Onion/Garlic, Fish

  • This sauce is not vegetarian. It contains Colatura di Alici, a fish sauce from Campania which is made from anchovies.

  • San Marzano Tomatoes, Red Wine Vinegar, Jimmy Nardello Peppers, Giant Marconi Peppers, Grilled Red Onions, Sherry Vinegar, Spring Water, Capperino Peppers, Colatura di Alici*, Garlic, Tomato Paste, Sea Salt, Dried Calabrian Peppers, Nutritional Yeast**, Italian Oregano, Parsley, Genovese Basil, Black Pepper, Calcium Disodium EDTA

    *Anchovies, Salt

    **Inactive Yeast (Inactive Yeast, Thiamine Hydrochloride [Vitamin B1], Riboflavin [Vitamin B2], Nicotinic Amide [Vitamin B3], Calcium D-Pantothenate [Vitamin B5], Pyridoxine Hydrochloride [Vitamin B6], Folic Acid [Vitamin B9], Cyanocobalamin [Vitamin B12], Zinc Sulfate).

  • Unlike all of the rest of our sauces, we grew very few peppers for this one. In fact, only the Giant Marconi peppers came from “Hot Sauce Farms.” The other fresh peppers came from Moon Valley Farm in Woodsboro, Maryland. The dried Calabrian peppers were imported from Italy by Alma Gourmet.

    The backbone of this sauce is undoubtedly the San Marzano tomatoes and those came entirely from Gorman Farms in Highland, Maryland.

    The red onions came from Sassafras Creek Farm, way down in Saint Mary’s County, Maryland. Pleasant Hill Produce in Walkersville, Maryland grew the garlic we used, and we added a LOT of it in this sauce. They also grew the basil.

    We used two vinegars in this sauce, the first and most important one was the red wine (or “Meritage”) vinegar from Keepwell Vinegars in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. The second was a touch of sherry vinegar from our favorite easy to find producer, Columela.

  • This sauce is a combination of two batches, one started in mid-August, the other in early October. Both batches contained fresh peppers and some dried calabrian peppers that we rehydrated in spring water prior to fermentation.

    The first batch fermented for about three month, the second for about two. The were then blended together, along with vinegar, spices and herbs and low-temperature pasteurized - roughly 147°F for forty minutes - prior to bottling in mid-December.

    • Brix: 17

    • pH: 3.2

Giant Marconi Peppers in Tim’s garden circa mid-August 2025